Power Struggle Part 1: ElectriCities Rates, Governor Calls Her Bill "Exorbitant"

There is a growing frustration all across Eastern Carolina over high utility bills, in particular from ElectriCities customers.

ElectriCities is the umbrella organization that oversees management of what's known as the North Carolina Eastern Municipal Power Agency made up of 32 municipalities across Eastern Carolina. Collectively they provide power to 268,000 customers. But they're paying more than customers at Progress, Duke and even electric co-ops.

The CEO of ElectriCities tells WITN the bills are as much as 35 percent higher. It has many residents fed up. Even Governor Beverly Perdue is questioning her personal bill at her New Bern home. So why are the bills so high and is anything being done about it?

Lois McClellan of New Bern was happy to get out and work in the yard recently on a nice day where it wasn't too hot or too cold. That also meant she didn't have to worry about spending money by turning on the heat or the air conditioning. "That's a big chunk of the budget, the utilities." Neighbor Durwood Johnson, who's retired and on a fixed income, feels the same. "I only have 1,600 square feet of floor space, heated space, it runs about $500 a month year round and that's a lot."

New Bern Mayor Lee Bettis says he's seen bills much higher than Johnson's, like $1,000 a month for a single wide and more. "The highest one I ever heard is $1,500 a month for an electric bill."

Even Governor Beverly Perdue is complaining about her bill. In March of 2009, she wrote then New Bern Mayor Tom Bayliss a personal letter, saying her most recent ElectriCities bill, "Sounds exorbitant." She goes on to say, "That bill was $537.57 for a house I have not been in since the preceding Christmas and where the thermostat was set at 64 degrees."

The governor's office tells me Perdue, speaking as a private citizen and resident of New Bern, believes the rates she and other ElectriCities customers pay are too high.

So just how many other customers feel the same way as the governor and have been complaining about ElectriCities rates? The governor's office says it doesn't have jurisdiction over such complaints. So what about the North Carolina Utilities Commission? Commission officials say they don't have oversight over ElectriCities and therefore don't handle those complaints. They referred us to the North Carolina Attorney General's Office. But representatives of the attorney general's office said they don't handle such complaints either and referred us to the North Carolina Rural Electrification Authority. And guess what? Officials at the authority say they don't handle those complaints either.

Graham Edwards, the CEO of ElectriCities, says aside from complaining to the city where a customer gets their bill, the place which sets the rates, there is no independent oversight. In response to a question that there is not an outside agency that regulates the municipalities that set the rates or ElectriCities, Edwards said, "That is correct."

While Edwards recommends customers take their complaints to city officials like the governor did, the governor's office says the letter she sent had no effect on her bill, or rates for other customers...bills that Edwards acknowledges are higher than what other power customers in North Carolina pay. "If you look at the cities in Eastern North Carolina that are members of the power agency, 20 to 35 percent higher than what Progress Energy would charge."

Recent rate increases contribute to the higher bills, but you have to go back decades to find the biggest reason. That's when ElectriCities bought into the construction of the Shearon Harris nuclear power plant in Wake County. Edwards says four units were to be built at a cost of one billion dollars. The accident at the Three Mile Island nuclear facility changed that and costs skyrocketed. Instead, they got one unit for four billion dollars. "It's easy to Monday morning quarterback but the folks that made that decision back in the early 80's, they did the right thing at the time. It's just it didn't turn out to be as good a deal as we thought."

And it's a deal customers today continue to pay for in the form of a 2.4 billion dollar debt. That debt is spread out over the 32 municipalities and passed on to its customers. Greenville's share is $364 million, $361 million in Rocky Mount, $350 million for Wilson, $196 million for Kinston, and $144 million for New Bern, just to name a few. That debt won't be paid off for another fifteen years.

New Bern Mayor Lee Bettis says if something isn't done about the rates the entire region could suffer. "People won't be able to move here, people won't be able to stay here, businesses won't locate here."

Residents like Durwood Johnson and Lois McClellan just want something done. Johnson says, "Ya know, I've been here since 74 and it's a fine town and I enjoy it but I do hate paying this high bill that I have to pay every month." McClellan added, "I wish something could be done. I don't know what, but there should be a solution."

WITN did ask the governor's office, in light of her sending that letter, if she is doing anything to try and lower rates. The answer was no. However, others are taking action and we'll take a look at that tomorrow at six.

If you are an ElectriCities customer, we would like to hear from you about your bill. You can send an email to dave.jordan@witn.com or contact him on facebook.


You must be logged in to post comments.

Username:
Password (case sensitive):
Remember Me:

Read Comments

Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
  • by Dumbo Location: Jolly Green Giant on Nov 13, 2011 at 09:52 AM
    Will someone REALLY show the relationship between The City of Greenville and GUC. Why is the City Manager of Greenville a voting member on the board of GUC. Again, IS GUC a government protected monolopy ??????????
  • by DUMBO Location: Duplicityville on May 25, 2011 at 06:33 AM
    ACTUAL GUC current customer bill: $16 higher than same billing cycle last yr. Last yr. house was FULLY occupied during the billing cycle. THIS year house NOT occupied for ( 11) ELEVEN days. (1) NO HEAT NOR AC TURNED on (2) WATER to house turned off from street (3) HOT WATER HEATER electric breaker cut off. REALLY SO all you who comment and say it's the way WE use electricity etc you are DUMB as well as INCORRECT>
  • by Henry Location: Kinston on May 10, 2011 at 09:27 AM
    I live on the City of Kinston electric system. I have a 2,000 square foot home built in 1999. I have never had an electric utility bill over $200.00. I keep my thermostat on 78 degrees when I'm not home in the summer and 65 degrees in the winter. I must be the exception since I take responsibility for how I use energy.
  • by Harrison Location: Greenville on May 9, 2011 at 08:17 AM
    Seems several cities have responded to this critical issue. Has any official in Greenvl. shown a bit of interest or tried to join with Mayors and Counsil members of other cities in an effort to help their citizens ???? Be happy to be so enlightened. What is the relationship between City of Greenvl., GUC & Electricities. Is GUC a Government protected monolopy ? One wonders. HATS OFF TO WITN AND DAVE JORDAN, WILSON NC COUNCIL & NEWSPAPER. At least Electricities debt is revealed as viable part of high bills. In 1999 we had the opportunity to be part of what is now Progress Energy and refused. Fools we remain. Greenvl. residents must have pots of money to throw away. Greenvl. residents think carefully about your votes for representation.
  • by spence451 Location: Plymouth on May 6, 2011 at 10:15 AM
    Progress Energy and Duke Power are both ways less than Dominion. To cut power on to a house in NC with Dominion is a little less then 3 times as much as it is in Va. It seems we are subsidising Va's power rates. As far as the Governors power rates go, she's a democrat politician and they support policies that as Obama says will necessarily cause power rates to skyrocket. As far as the new wind farm goes the power should be used to lower northeastern NC's power rates instead of going on the grid to help other states and areas power rates.
  • by dEE Location: Greenville on May 5, 2011 at 04:11 PM
    Someone needs to look into GUC too. They are the worst 500 dollar plus light bills, no payment arrg. they are just awful. We need some competition in the area so we can pick who we go with and not just a monooply. GUC is making so much money off of its citizens. 25 dollar backyard fee. CRAZY! LAWYERS get on GUC sue them blind!
  • by ignorance starts at home on May 5, 2011 at 03:33 PM
    So many of you seem to not understand that you can dramatically reduce your bill by just getting educated. You pay the same for what you use as you do for what you needlessly waste.
  • by David Location: Goldsboro on May 5, 2011 at 03:10 PM
    That's the very reason why I moved from Kinston. I got tired of giving the City Of Kinston all my hard earned money. When I moved from Kinston I went from paying 400 to 500 dollars a month to 160 dollars a month with Progress Energy with the same size house. I have no idea why you people are just giving your money away like that every month because that's all your doing is just giving it away.
  • by David Location: Goldsboro on May 5, 2011 at 03:10 PM
    That's the very reason why I moved from Kinston. I got tired of giving the City Of Kinston all my hard earned money. When I moved from Kinston I went from paying 400 to 500 dollars a month to 160 dollars a month with Progress Energy with the same size house. I have no idea why you people are just giving your money away like that every month because that's all your doing is just giving it away.
  • by KT Location: Chocowinity on May 5, 2011 at 02:11 PM
    WHY are people on here giving Progress Energy rave reviews? I'm with PE and my bill is always extremely high $500 a month for 2100 sqft. If it snows or gets above 90 degrees look out my bill will double for that month. I have called and complained but what choice do I have but to pay it.
WITN

275 E. Arlington Blvd. Greenville, NC 27858 252-439-7777
Copyright © 2002-2016 - Designed by Gray Digital Media - Powered by Clickability 121286184 - witn.com/a?a=121286184
Gray Television, Inc.