Lawsuit Last Option For Coleman In Minn. Recount

The morning after the Nov. 4 election, Norm Coleman stood before TV cameras, declared victory in Minnesota's U.S. Senate election and said that if he were opponent Al Franken he'd "step aside."

Two months later, Coleman finds himself down by nearly the same margin he appeared to hold over Franken that day. His lawyers said Coleman — who later expressed regret at that post-election remark — is not ready to step aside, vowing a lawsuit that's likely to keep the race in limbo for several more months.

Minnesota's Canvassing Board on Monday certified that Democrat Franken won 225 more votes than Republican Coleman, out of almost 3 million cast. Franken took his own opportunity to declare himself the victor.

"I am proud to stand before you as the next senator from Minnesota," the former "Saturday Night Live" personality told reporters in brief remarks outside his downtown Minneapolis condominium.

But Franken's ability to claim the seat immediately is in doubt. Minnesota law prohibits final certification of a winner until a legal challenge is resolved, and Senate Republicans have indicated they would filibuster if necessary to block Franken from participating when new senators are sworn in Tuesday.

Franken took no questions during his brief appearance Monday, and his campaign aides refused to reveal if he would be in Washington on Tuesday to try to participate in the swearing-in.

Coleman, whose term in office ended on Saturday, was in Washington when the Canvassing Board declared him the loser of the recount. His campaign said he would speak publicly in Minnesota on Tuesday.

The Canvassing Board's certification of the recount results started a seven-day clock for Coleman to file a lawsuit. His attorney, Tony Trimble, said Monday afternoon that the challenge would be filed within 24 hours.

"This process isn't at an end," Trimble said. "It is now just at the beginning."

When the smoke cleared after the election, Coleman appeared to hold a 215-vote lead. But Franken made up the deficit over seven tortuous weeks of ballot-sifting, in part by prevailing on more challenges that both campaigns brought to thousands of ballots.

Franken also did better than Coleman when election officials opened and counted more than 900 absentee ballots that had erroneously been disqualified on Election Day.

Coleman's lawyers have argued that some ballots were mishandled and others were wrongly excluded from the recount, giving Franken an unfair advantage. Such claims are likely to be a major feature of any lawsuit.

Secretary of State Mark Ritchie, a Democrat, was careful to note that the board was simply signing off on the numbers found by the recount: Franken, with 1,212,431 votes, and Coleman, with 1,212,206 votes.

"We're not doing anything today that declares winners or losers or anything to that effect," Ritchie said.

All five members of the canvassing board — Ritchie, plus two state Supreme Court justices and two Ramsey County judges — voted to accept the recount results. And the four judges, including two appointees of Republican governors, praised Ritchie and his staff as being fair and diligent.

A lawsuit would extend the fight over the seat for months. Any court case would open doors closed to the campaigns during the administrative recount. They would be able to access voter rolls, inspect machines and get testimony from election workers.

The case would fall to a three-judge panel picked by Chief Justice Eric Magnuson of the Supreme Court. Magnuson served on the Canvassing Board, but declined to say Monday if he would remove himself from the selection process as a result. Magnuson was an appointee of Republican Gov. Tim Pawlenty.

Costs of the election lawsuit fall to the campaigns. But there is a provision in state law that exposes the government to costs if prior results are reversed due to an irregularity in election procedure.

You must be logged in to post comments.

Password (case sensitive):
Remember Me:

Read Comments

Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
  • by wr Location: nc on Jan 6, 2009 at 05:58 PM
    I just can't imagine how that many people voted for "Me Al Franken" he still resembles his SNL character.
  • by Tad Location: Jamesville on Jan 6, 2009 at 10:50 AM
    If I lived in a state that elected a dufus like Al Franken to any office I would move.
  • by VBush Location: MHCY on Jan 6, 2009 at 05:54 AM
    The fact that the vote count was even close says much about the knowledge (or lack thereof) of the average voter. Most know little to nothing about the people they vote for. This is a prime case of ignorance run rampant. If it weren't for the sheep......
  • by Obama Snake Oil Co Location: Washington on Jan 6, 2009 at 05:34 AM
    Just this morning Fox gave more detail on this story. Why NBC doesn't cover this is perplexing. Apparently, counts from the different precints outnumbered the amount of registered voters. How can that be? Well, Soros really wants Minn under his control. Yes, if you don't know about this guy you should as he does control a lot of politics with the use of his power and money. You that voted democrat are supporting him. This is the change you can believe in and what you voted for, didn't know that? I think the next 4 years will reveal corruption never heard of in government.
  • by Jimbo Location: NC on Jan 6, 2009 at 05:04 AM
    Franken is a joke but what can you expect from a state that elects Jesse "the body" Ventura for governor. Franken was not even good in his primary career as a comedian. I guess now we'll see if he can walk the walk. We all certainly know that he can talk.
  • by fred Location: nc on Jan 6, 2009 at 03:55 AM
    I do not know of a politician more irritating than Al Frankin.He reminds me of the NBC newsman Kieth Oberman. Both think they are so much more intelligant than everyone else.I wonder if either ever did a hard days work where they used more than just their mouth.

275 E. Arlington Blvd. Greenville, NC 27858 252-439-7777
Copyright © 2002-2016 - Designed by Gray Digital Media - Powered by Clickability 37135834 -
Gray Television, Inc.