Liberals Unhappy With Obama's Latest Move

WASHINGTON (AP) -- President Barack Obama's weekend concession on a health care "government option" drew complaints from liberals and scarce interest from Republicans and other critics on Monday, a fresh sign of the challenge in finding middle ground in an increasingly partisan political struggle.

"You really can't do health reform" without allowing the government to compete with private insurers, said Howard Dean, a former Democratic Party chairman. "Let's not say we're doing health reform without a public option," he added in a slap at the administration's latest move.

Obama and his top aides signaled retreat over the weekend on proposals for a provision under which consumers could choose from health insurance policies sold by the federal government as well as those marketed by private companies. "All I'm saying is, though, that the public option, whether we have it or we don't have it, is not the entirety of health care reform," the president told a town hall-style audience in Grand Junction, Colo., on Saturday. "This is just one sliver of it, one aspect of it."

The government option has emerged as one of the most contentious elements of legislation taking shape in Congress, with critics saying it is a step toward a federal takeover of health care and supporters arguing it is essential to create competition with private firms.

Proposals for creation of nonprofit co-operative ventures have emerged as an alternative, but so far, neither liberals nor conservatives have shown great interest.

Obama made his remarks as he struggled to regain momentum for a health care overhaul that has generated controversy among Democrats and near unanimous opposition among Republicans. Recent polls show a lessening of support, and the administration and its allies were thrown on the defensive earlier this month when angry protesters turned up at widely publicized town hall events held by Democratic lawmakers.

The bill faces numerous obstacles when lawmakers return to the Capitol after Labor Day.

In the House, where Democrats hold a 256-178 majority, passage of legislation will hinge on the ability of the administration and Democratic leaders to satisfy liberals who favor a robust government option and centrists who prefer the co-op approach.

Because they cannot realistically count on any Republican votes, the margin for error is reduced. At the same time, House leaders want to protect their rank-and-file centrists, who tend to come from swing districts, and whose victories in 2006 and 2008 helped give the party its large majority.

There are similar Democratic divisions in the Senate, where the party controls 60 seats to 40 for the Republicans. A bipartisan group of six senators has been meeting for weeks on a possible compromise that would not include a government option. It is not clear whether they will be successful in reaching a final agreement.

While the president says he favors a bipartisan approach, he has also said it may ultimately be necessary for Democrats to produce a bill more to their own liking.

Jim Manley, spokesman for Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, said the Nevada lawmaker "supports a public option" because it could keep insurance companies in check. "But he also knows that 60 votes will be needed to get anything done. Senator Reid recognizes there are different proposals on the table that could accomplish this goal," the spokesman said, a clear reference to the co-op alternative.

Liberals in and out of Congress were careful not to criticize Obama directly, but they made clear their unhappiness with his latest move.

Dean made his remarks in interviews on NBC and CBS. He and Obama are not close, and the administration snubbed the former party chairman earlier this year when it did not invite him to be present when his successor was named.

"Leaving private insurance companies the job of controlling the costs of health care is like making a pyromaniac the fire chief," said Rep., Anthony Weiner, D-N.Y. Weiner is one of dozens of Democrats who favor creation of a so-called "single payer" approach under which the government would take over the health care system. For many of them, the government option represents a significant retreat.

Rep. Barbara Lee, D-Calif., who chairs the Congressional Black Caucus, issued a statement that called the weekend administration statements deeply troubling. "The Congressional Black Caucus remains committed to ensuring that health reform is meaningful, and that means making sure that a public option is part of the package," she said.

The Senate Republican leader, Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, issued a statement that emphasized other complaints about Obama's proposals.

"While both political parties believe we need to reform our health care system, particularly in the areas of cost and access, Americans are rightly skeptical about the administration's approach to overhauling everyone's health care and about the more than $1 trillion price tag. Moreover, Americans are concerned about funding new government programs through massive cuts to Medicare and taxes on small business," he said

He called for concentrating on other areas, including curbs on medical liability lawsuits, wellness programs and a tax break to help everyone afford coverage.

You must be logged in to post comments.

Password (case sensitive):
Remember Me:

Read Comments

Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
  • by MrT Location: LaNC on Aug 18, 2009 at 06:32 PM
    I see Lavon is back on the other story about assault weapons at a Obama rally, but he still hasn't had anything to say about this one, has he?
  • by mo votes on Aug 18, 2009 at 06:10 PM
    Liberials worring about re-election. They gotta make themselves look good!
  • by Obama Snake Oil Co Location: Washington on Aug 18, 2009 at 05:42 AM
    Tim, be nice to lavon, he is having a bad day. He is actually, having to do his job. Medicare and Medicaid have problems, yes, but cut it by 300 billion? Like I said, don't wake the sleeping giant, oopps, too late. The elderaly are more powerfull than the liberals, trust me, the numbers are there. Barlow, competition is good! Just remember, its expensive for BC/BS to support all of the poor and illegals you party wants in this state. You question that? Look who has control of the state, democrats.
  • by Barlow Location: Winterville on Aug 18, 2009 at 05:08 AM
    45 million people are already on Medicare or Medicaid. Most people like it and don't want it to go away. Some don't even realize these are government programs. Notice in my first post that Blue Cross/Blue Shield wanted a 56% increase but they only allowed a MERE 22% hike by regulators. And you are afraid the government is getting into you wallet? LOL
  • by Bob Location: Belhaven on Aug 17, 2009 at 07:24 PM
    Say it ain't so! "the one" has dissention in the ranks. I bet the beer is flowing in the white house now! You know if it is good enough for us, then it should be good enough for "the one" and congress! I guess this was the issue to finally awaken some of these blind followers! If you lie all the time, it will eventually catch up with you! I guess he found out that even the and the gang (pepsiosi and barnie and the rest) can't keep messing over the American people. Even the dumb ones wake up eventually!
  • by Angus Location: NC on Aug 17, 2009 at 06:13 PM
    Wolfgang is right why companies like UPS & FedEx become mailing companies? Why? Your mail gets delieverd to the right place. I still get postal mail all the time that is not mine. I just return to sender. If the Gov't can not run the American postal service right. How could they run a Nationasl health care system?
  • by Robert Location: NC on Aug 17, 2009 at 05:15 PM
    Obama's gift of say anything the people want to here to get elected. Like getting a redistrubtion check from the rich people days are over. He can not pay for it he ran America out of $$$$$. Obama just lost the trust of the ones who got him elected the liberals.
  • by MrT Location: LaNC on Aug 17, 2009 at 05:01 PM
    WITN, what the heck is the deal? Is this the day that you choose to not post my comment on this story?Have I said anything any worse than Tim did below?
  • by Tim Location: Wilmar on Aug 17, 2009 at 05:00 PM
    Thanks guys, I am sick of Lavon cramming Obama down our throats. Turn about is fair play! Happy voting starting in 2010 folks! Say good bye to your liberals while you still can. Some liberal old-timers will be saying farewell in the coming elections!......Thank God!
  • by bigfruitbasket Location: NC on Aug 17, 2009 at 04:54 PM
    Dear liberals: get over it! Thank you, the critical thinking public.
  • Page:

275 E. Arlington Blvd. Greenville, NC 27858 252-439-7777
Copyright © 2002-2016 - Designed by Gray Digital Media - Powered by Clickability 53478142 -
Gray Television, Inc.